-the redhead- (theredhead) wrote,
-the redhead-

I'm mystified - MD Sheep & Wool criteria or What is Novelty Yarn?

What is novelty yarn?

Here's the note I just submitted to one of the spinning lists in hopes of getting some clue:

I have a question re: the MD Sheep & Wool skein competition criteria that I'm hoping someone here can shed some light on. I'm a little mystified as to why one of my skeins wasn't judged at all. Is beaded yarn not a novelty style yarn? Or maybe I was mistaken in thinking that binder (sewing thread) is not acceptable under the MDSW guidelines? I ask this, because at every other competition I have entered such yarn it has definitely been considered novelty yarn. Also, I was wondering who the skein judge at MDSW was.


They did not even judge my black beaded skein. I got a little note back that says:

Very beautiful result, but as far as we can tell the beaded binder yarn was not constructed, so this is not a novelty spinning technique

I'm confused by this note. Both myself and my mentor (and several other judges) have considered creating a 2-ply binder (from the individual parts of beads and thread) S-spun, spinning a single S, and then plying everything together Z to definitely be a novelty yarn technique. Sooo what am I missing here?

The only other thought I came up with (based on 'as far as we can tell the beaded binder yarn was not constructed') is they, for some *crazy* reason, think that I purchased the 2-ply binder with beads already on it because it's somehow 'too good' to be hand-done? Which, I suppose, it pretty darned flattering, but still...

-the redhead-
...confused and somewhat disappointed...
Tags: spinning
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.